Abigail vs Scarlett
Head-to-head: full US statistics and history since 1880.
Abigail
a name gently stepping back from its peak
- Rank today
- #41
- Peak
- #4 (2005)
- Babies in 2025
- 4,941
- Classroom
- likely the only one
- Strongest states
- CA, TX, FL
VS
Scarlett
a name gently stepping back from its peak
- Rank today
- #32
- Peak
- #14 (2022)
- Babies in 2025
- 5,644
- Classroom
- likely the only one
- Strongest states
- CA, TX, NY
The verdict
Scarlett is the more popular pick (#32 vs #41). Both sit in a similar popularity band — Scarlett is a name gently stepping back from its peak, Abigail is a name gently stepping back from its peak.
Can't decide alone?
Create a vote pool and let family and friends pick the winner — they vote free, no signup.